The Best and The Most Disappointing Breweries of 2023!

Posted byPosted inBreweriesTags:, , , , , , , , , , , ,














































































During my travels this year, I went from coast to coast, exploring states in the north and south. Along the way, I made it sure to visit various breweries in each city I stopped by. The tally came up to a whopping 40 breweries, and needless to say, I had a few favorites and not-so-impressive ones.

Let’s start with what, I believe, makes a great taproom or brewery. It’s not just about serving fantastic beer; it’s about creating an inviting atmosphere that makes you want to stay and savor your drink, whether you’re alone or with friends.

Now, let’s talk beer. CraftHaus blew me away with its intricate flavors, while Howard Street’s (sadly, now closed) Red Rye Redemption was a truly delightful surprise. While in Seattle, a friendly bartender introduced me to an unfamiliar brewery that quickly won me over – Stoup Brewing. Their beers were not only tasty but also showcased the city’s thriving craft beer scene. And in Boston, Democracy Brewing became my go-to spot, especially for their delectable 1916 brew.

When the time came to choose the most notable picks, I didn’t take it lightly. Let’s start with the most disappointing one – that was a relatively easy decision to make.

The Most Disappointing

disappointing pot pie brunch

This may have been the newest brewery that I visited this year, but it also had a lot to live up to. I had been waiting for months for the opportunity for it to open. When I was finally able to visit the bar was busy and less than impressive. I arrived for their brunch and sat at the one of there few spots open at the bar. There was a sewage smell coming from the sink, and we were off… 

I ordered a “pot pie” for brunch and received a $16 bowl of spicy tomato soup with some feta cheese plus a fried egg. There was no “pie” in the pie. It was tasty but not a pot pie.

disappointing pot pie brunch

This may have been the newest brewery that I visited this year, but it also had a lot to live up to. I had been waiting for months for the opportunity for it to open. When I was finally able to visit the bar was busy and less than impressive. I arrived for their brunch and sat at the one of there few spots open at the bar. There was a sewage smell coming from the sink, and we were off… 

I ordered a “pot pie” for brunch and received a $16 bowl of spicy tomato soup with some feta cheese plus a fried egg. There was no “pie” in the pie. It was tasty but not a pot pie.

The beer was of course the main reason I went. Although known for one particular beer, they offer a variety of others and I wanted to try a few. They did not serve flights, which is always frustrating and confusing to me, so I tried a couple of pints before diving into the main coarse. They were alright, but nothing to get too excited about. I tried a red ale with breakfast tea as well as an oat stout. We also got a Hazy IPA to go, in the over-sized gift shop. I mean a brewery with a gift shop and Cafe come on… I then tried the Draught Stout, hoping that it would take me back to Ireland and the delicious flavors of fresh, bitter, creamy deliciousness.

Guinness Opengate Chicago

The part that kills me about this is that Guinness Draught Stout is my favorite beer, and I have visited the St. James Gate Brewery in Dublin. It probably sounds like a cliché, but the beer over there is so much better than the beer available in the US. I was hoping that since this is an official Guinness brewery they would have a direct line to the good stuff, and their Guinness would taste like that in Ireland. Unfortunately it tasted like any other decent Guinness in the US. Just sort of ehh…by comparison. 

I think the tourists with their suitcases in-toe summed the experience up. After all my excitement it left me wanting. They clearly spent a lot of money on the space, and it’s well put together. However, it’s cold and uninviting and the staff seemed less than excited to be there.

Slainte

My Favorite

My Favorite brwery
My Favorite Brewery Logo

When it came to choosing the best brewery of 2023, I found it to be quite a difficult decision. There were numerous breweries that stood out as truly remarkable places to visit. However, what truly mattered to me was finding a brewery that made me feel comfortable and served up some stellar beers.

St. Elmo Brewing Company exceeded my expectations on every level. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with friendly and knowledgeable staff eager to engage in pleasant conversations. The atmosphere was inviting and fun, creating the perfect backdrop for a memorable experience.

Favorite beer list at St. Elmo

What impressed me most were the outstanding beers they had to offer. From the Sonny – Red IPA, to the Freckles – American Brown Ale, each brew was crafted with care and precision. It was evident that the brewery took pride in their work and are committed to crafting quality beer. The names of the beers, inspired by the characters in The Sandlot, added a touch of nostalgia and whimsy to the experience.

During my visit to Austin, a good friend of mine highly recommended St. Elmo Brewing Company, and I’m glad I followed his advice. It was an adventure that I won’t soon forget.

Complete Brewery List

In order of visit

Complete Brewery List

In order of visit

Where Should I Go in 2024?

I would love to know your favorite places to visit. Let me know in the comments section.

Cheers!

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.